Middle East Monitor- Janaury 22, 2024
Hamas: 7 October was necessary to confront Israel’s plans
Hamas said yesterday that the 7 October resistance operation on Israel was a “necessary step” to confront the Israeli plans aimed at “liquidating the Palestinian cause”.
In an 18-page report on the attack, released in Arabic and English, the movement said the Palestinian people’s struggle with the Israeli occupation and colonialism did not begin on 7 October 2023, but with 30 years of British colonialism and 75 years of Zionist occupation.
The Al-Aqsa Flood Operation, it explained, “was a necessary step and a normal response to confront all Israeli conspiracies against the Palestinian people and their cause. It was a defensive act in the frame of getting rid of the Israeli occupation, reclaiming the Palestinian rights and on the way for liberation and independence like all peoples around the world did.”
On 7 October, Hamas launched an unprecedented attack on Israeli army sites and towns and villages near the Gaza Strip, capturing some 240 prisoners of war.
In its document, Hamas denied Israeli reports claiming it had targeted civilians during the attack, and stressed that “avoiding harm to civilians, especially children, women and elderly people is a religious and moral commitment by all the Al-Qassam Brigades’ fighters. We reiterate that the Palestinian resistance was fully disciplined and committed to the Islamic values during the operation.” Adding that “the resistance does not possess precise weapons” and therefore some civilians may have been injured “accidently and in the course of the confrontation with the occupation forces.”
Claims by the occupation state that resistance fighters had purposely targeted “Israeli civilians are nothing but complete lies and fabrications,” it continued.
As attested by many, the Hamas Movement dealt in a positive and kind manner with all civilians who have been held in Gaza.
Calling for “the immediate halt of the Israeli aggression on Gaza, the crimes and ethnic cleansing committed against the entire Gaza population,” it added: “The Israeli occupation’s use of the “self-defence” pretext to justify its oppression against the Palestinian people is a process of lie, deception and turning the facts. The Israeli entity has no right to defend its crimes and occupation but the Palestinian people who have such right to oblige the occupier to end the occupation.”
It said it rejects international and Israeli plans to decide “the future of Gaza”, which according to its assertions, “only serve to prolong the occupation.”
“We urge for standing against the Israeli attempts to cause another wave of expulsion – or a new Nakba.”
Since 7 October, Israel has killed more than 25,000 Palestinians in Gaza and injured more than 60,000. Settler violence in the occupied West Bank has also increased, with 358 Palestinians killed since the aggression on Gaza began, this includes 91 children.
https://www.middleeastmonitor.com/20240122-hamas-7-october-was-necessary-to-confront-israels-plans/
Le Monde with AFP – January 21, 2024
Hamas says October 7 attacks 'necessary step' but admits to 'faults'
The Palestinian group issued a public report explaining its motivations for the October 7 and calling for an 'immediate halt of the Israeli aggression.' Israel's Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said he rejected the conditions demanded for the release of hostages.
Palestinian militant group Hamas said Sunday, January 21, its October 7 attacks in southern Israel were a "necessary step" against Israeli occupation of the Palestinian territories. But the Islamist group admitted in a 16-page report justifying the attack that "some faults happened... due to the rapid collapse of the Israeli security and military system, and the chaos caused along the border areas with Gaza."
The document was the group's first public report released in English and Arabic explaining the background to the attack, when the militants broke through Gaza's militarized border. At the end of a Jewish holiday on October 7, hundreds of Hamas fighters crossed into Israel by land, air and sea and killed civilians in the streets, in their homes and at an outdoor rave party.
"If there was any case of targeting civilians it happened accidently and in the course of the confrontation with the occupation forces," Hamas said in the report. "Many Israelis were killed by the Israeli army and police due to their confusion."
The attack resulted in the deaths of about 1,140 people, mostly civilians, according to an AFP tally based on official Israeli figures. Around 700 Israeli civilians and 76 foreigners were among the dead, with one Israeli still missing, according to Israeli social security data. During the attack, the gunmen seized around 250 hostages, according to the latest Israeli figures. Israeli officials say around 132 captives remain in Gaza, of whom at least 27 are believed to have been killed.
'Halt Israeli aggression'
Israel retaliated to the attacks by declaring a war to destroy Hamas, pounding the Gaza Strip in the deadliest bombing campaign the area has ever faced. Israel deployed tens of thousands of troops along the Gaza frontier and on the northern border with Lebanon. It declared a complete siege of Gaza, cutting off supplies of water, electricity and food, decisions denounced by the United Nations. Israel's retaliation has killed at least 25,105 people in Gaza, mostly women, children and adolescents, according to the health ministry in the territory.
Israeli officials have repeatedly alleged that the militants committed gang rape, genital mutilation and engaged in sexual acts with children and corpses during the attack. Hamas has rejected the accusations, saying they were intended to "demonize" it.
Hamas said the attack was "a necessary step and a normal response to confront all Israeli conspiracies against the Palestinian people." The militant group urged "the immediate halt of the Israeli aggression on Gaza, the crimes and ethnic cleansing committed against the entire Gaza population." And it said it rejected any international and Israeli efforts to decide Gaza's post-war future. "We stress that the Palestinian people have the capacity to decide their future and to arrange their internal affairs," the report said, adding that "no party in the world" had the right to decide on their behalf.
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said on Sunday he had rejected the conditions demanded by Hamas militants for the release of hostages, hours after the group released the report. "In exchange for the release of our hostages, Hamas demands an end to the war, the withdrawal of our forces from Gaza, the release of all murderers.... If we accept this, our soldiers have fallen in vain. If we accept this, we won't be able to guarantee the safety of our citizens," Netanyahu said.
Hamas pointed to the historical origins of the conflict, saying "the battle of the Palestinian people against occupation and colonialism did not start on October 7, but started 105 years ago, including 30 years of British colonialism and 75 years of Zionist occupation." The group said it wanted to "hold the Israeli occupation legally accountable" for the suffering it had inflicted on the Palestinian people.
Hamas document explains October 7 attack,
calls on international community to end Israeli occupation
Hamas put forth a set of demands to the international community in a document titled, “This is our story… Why Operation al-Aqsa Flood?” released by the Gaza government media office on Sunday.
The release comes amid reports claiming that Hamas and Israel have shown willingness to resume negotiations for a second prisoner exchange deal, which Hamas officials have conditioned upon a comprehensive ceasefire agreement.
The demands include:
Calling for “an immediate cessation of the Israeli aggression on the Gaza Strip and urgent action to halt [Israeli] crimes and genocide.”
Opening border crossings, lifting the blockade on Gaza and the entry of humanitarian aid and necessary resources for shelter and reconstruction.
Calling for legal action to be taken against the Israeli occupation and for “accountability for the suffering and losses endured by the victims,” as well as “supporting the resistance against Israeli occupation through all available means.”
Appealing to the “free nations of the world,” particularly those who have experienced colonialism or occupation and “fully comprehend the plight of the Palestinian people, especially countries in the Global South,” and any state or entity that stands by the principles of justice. They call upon these countries to take a “serious and effective stance against the double standards exercised by powers supporting Israeli occupation.”
Launching a global movement in solidarity with the Palestinian people and the rejection of any international or Israeli project that seeks to determine the future of the Gaza Strip based on the Occupation’s criteria, perpetuating its continuation. They also urge serious efforts to compel the Occupation to withdraw.
Standing against attempts to displace Palestinians in the Occupied Territories of 1948, the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, stating that there should be “no displacement to Sinai, Jordan, or any other place. If there is any movement of refugees, it should be their return to their homes from which they were expelled in 1948.”
Stressing the need to continue popular pressure, both Arab and Islamic, as well as international, to end the occupation, mobilize calls rejecting normalization and boycott Israeli goods, as well as companies and institutions supporting the Occupation.
Urging the International Criminal Court, particularly the prosecutor and their investigative team, as well as relevant UN investigation committees, to “urgently and immediately come to occupied Palestine to investigate all crimes and violations, rather than rely on remote monitoring or succumbing to Israeli constraints.”
Apart from the demands, Hamas dedicated a significant portion of the document to refute what it referred to as Israeli falsehoods regarding Hamas’ treatment of Israeli civilians during Operation al-Aqsa Flood on October 7. Specifically addressed are claims that the Ezz Eddin al-Qassam Brigades intentionally targeted civilians, children and used sexual violence as a weapon.
Why Operation al-Aqsa Flood?
Hamas stated that its operation targeted Israeli military sites which Hamas claims “have always been a launching point for shelling and firing on Gaza and its people” and aimed to capture soldiers and fighters in order to secure the release of thousands of Palestinian prisoners held by the Occupation through a prisoners exchange deal. Therefore, it argued, the attack focused on the Israeli military unit in Gaza and military sites in the settlements surrounding Gaza.
In addition to refuting Israeli claims about the events of October 7, the document presented Hamas’ reasons for launching Operation al- Aqsa Flood. It described it as a natural response to “confront Israeli schemes aimed at the eradication of the Palestinian cause, controlling and Judaizing the land, and asserting sovereignty over the Aqsa Mosque and other holy sites.”
The operation, it said, was a necessary step toward ending the unjust siege on Gaza, in the Palestinian quest for liberation from occupation, restoration of national rights, attainment of independence and freedom, exercising the right to self-determination, and establishing an independent Palestinian state with Jerusalem as its capital.
While emphasizing that “Hamas, in accordance with international law, treaties and conventions, is a national liberation movement with legitimate goals and means,” the document clarifies that the conflict with the “Zionist project” is not a conflict with Jews based on their religion. Instead, “it is a struggle against the Zionists because they are occupiers who violate our people, land and sanctities.”
Conversely, “it is the Zionists who adopt religious claims and insist on imposing the Jewish nature of ‘Israel’ based on religious and nationalist backgrounds, while oppressing the Palestinian people and depriving them of their rights.”
Targeting civilians
Although Israel’s social security agency has identified 1,139 dead on October 7, including 695 civilians, Hamas stressed its adherence to avoiding the targeting of civilians on that day in its document, especially women, children and the elderly, as part of a religious and moral commitment, and despite lacking precision weaponry. It pointed out that any such incidents were “unintentional, perhaps due to the full and rapid collapse of the Israeli security and military system during Operation al-Aqsa Flood, as well as the ensuing chaos due to extensive breaches in the barrier and separation system between the Gaza Strip and [Hamas’] operational areas.”
In response to allegations that it targeted civilians on October 7, Hamas said that the “video footage taken on that day and the testimonies from Israelis that were later published, proved that Qassam fighters did not target civilians, but that many of them were killed at the hands of Israeli police and army forces due to their confusion.” Hamas also pointed to verified evidence which countered the false claim of the killing of 40 Israeli infants.
The Hamas document cited reports from the Israeli newspapers Yedioth Ahronoth and Haaretz, about the deaths of Israeli civilians on October 7 as a result of Israeli Apache helicopters opening fire on the attendees of the Nova festival near the Re’im settlement, where 364 people were killed. Haaretz cited an unnamed Israel Police official for its article but the Israel Police have since refuted this claim in a statement.
Hamas stated that its fighters arrived at the scene without prior knowledge of the festival and that Israeli pilots fired their shells and bullets indiscriminately.
The document also quoted Israeli testimonies which placed the blame on Israeli military raids and operations for the deaths of a large number of Israelis captured in settlements in Gaza’s vicinity, “where they bombed and destroyed houses during clashes with the resistance on October 7 and the following days.”
The document adds, “additional evidence of the above is the Israeli occupation authorities’ manipulation of the number of Israeli casualties on October 7. Initially, they claimed that 1,400 Israelis, including soldiers and settlers, were killed. However, weeks later, they reduced the number to 1,200, under the pretext that around 200 charred bodies were found to belong to Qassam fighters.”
Clashes with armed settlers
Hamas further stated that there were “armed settlers in Gaza’s vicinity who clashed with the resistance on October 7 and participated in military operations alongside Occupation forces. Those who were killed among them were registered as Israeli civilian casualties.”
Sexual violence
The movement vehemently denied allegations of Palestinian resistance fighters sexually assaulting Israeli women, stating that these claims have been proven false. They referred to a paper published by Mondoweiss on December 1, 2023, which thoroughly investigated and debunked all rape allegations.
|
Published since July 2008 |
Your donation
is tax deductable.
The Journal of America Team:
Editor in chief:
Abdus Sattar Ghazali
Senior Editor:
Prof. Arthur Scott
Special Correspondent
Maryam Turab
